Treading with Care upon the Earth
Working in Indian Country Respectfully to Meet the Challenges and Seize the Opportunities
By Marsha Katz, Organizational Consultant at The Rural Institute
"Where no one intrudes,
many can live in harmony." Chief Can George
Self-employment is a challenging endeavor for anyone. For persons
with disabilities living on a reservation, it can present even
more challenges—challenges that are unique to each specific
community, and challenges that are fairly common throughout Indian
Country.
When rehabilitation professionals on reservations partner with people with disabilities, their families, and others to creatively meet the challenges of self-employment, the benefits are many. Individuals benefit when they actualize their dreams and use their abilities to contribute to their community. The community benefits by gaining a product or service it needs, which also contributes to the greater community economic development. As the individual begins to realize profit from the business, some of that money also gets reinvested in the community when the business owner purchases other goods and services. Some businesses grow enough to create additional jobs in the community, and other businesses find they are more successful if several people bring together their products/services and work cooperatively for the benefit of the group. Self-employment in Indian Country is a circular endeavor where “individual” and “community” are entwined cooperatively to nourish both.
Anyone from outside an Indian community who wishes to partner with people with disabilities inside the community would do well to keep several things in mind, because herein lie some of the challenges that must be met if opportunities are to seized.
Community as Experts
First and foremost is the reality that the people in and of the community are the real experts. Those of us who are invited into the community to assist may bring ideas and expertise, but we are merely sharing what we know in a way that sort of resembles a Chinese menu. The “diners” of the community are the ones who must then pick and choose from our offerings what they think might make sense in their community. Then they may reshape it for use in a way that is appropriate to the community as well as the person who is starting a business. The wonderful byproduct for those of us coming from the outside is that we have an equal opportunity to learn new things and new ways.
In one Indian community where we at the Rural Institute have consulted, the general unemployment rate is about 80%. Jobs are scarce for everyone, not just for persons with disabilities. Even when jobs do come open, it is uncomfortable for the community’s rehabilitation professionals to promote some of the people they are assisting as candidates to fill those jobs. The reason for their discomfort is the fact that the persons with disabilities all have SSI and/or SSDI benefits, meaning they have at least enough to survive. Others in the community have no income whatsoever, so a job for them means food and clothing and maybe even shelter. The rehabilitation staff have explained to us that it would not be appropriate for people who have “something” to compete for more against people who have basically “nothing.” That was not their way, and it wasn’t a way to promote the feeling of “community.”
This challenge is easily converted into an opportunity by exploring possibilities for self-employment. If jobs are scarce, then needed goods and service probably are, too. What better way to invest in a community than to direct our human and financial resources toward helping persons with disabilities start businesses to fill those product and service gaps.
Sovereignty
A second thing to be aware of when partnering with Indian communities is that tribes and reservations are sovereign entities. As sovereign nations, each tribe and/or reservation has its own distinct personality and characteristics. Customs vary and languages are different, as are geography, size of tribes, and their land base. Some tribes and reservations are close to metropolitan areas while others are hours away by car, boat, plane, sled, or snowmobile. Some reservations are only a few acres and others span hundreds of miles across several states. Consultants and non-Indian rehabilitation professionals must allow themselves time to get to know the community, and for the community to get to know them. Building relationships, showing respect for the culture, and earning trust are necessities if one is to partner successfully with Indian communities. Our challenge is to suspend whatever romantic or stereotypic notions we may come with, in favor of just being respectful and open to learning.
With the community the challenges to rehabilitation professionals and small business owners with disabilities are as varied as the nature of each tribe, village, corporation, and reservation. In some of the communities where we’ve worked, the tribal council or other governing bodies choose to, or assume they must, approve each business that begins in the community. Decisions can seem, and may in fact be, arbitrary—based on “politics,” perception of people, or simply a lack of process. In other communities, businesses and tribal government are separated by miles, and oversight is minimal, unless a problem for the community arises. Where there is a Tribal Vocational Rehabilitation (VR) Program, also know as a Section 121 Program (Rehabilitation Act), funding from the federal government flows through tribal administration to the program. Few tribal staff, councils, and others in administration are familiar with the regulations and parameters that govern operation of the Tribal VR programs. This lack of knowledge can result in a tribal government mistakenly seeking to “micro-manage” funds that only Tribal VR programs have federal authority to spend.
If a reservation is a more closed community, which seeks to deliver all its own services from within the community, a business that draws many customers from the outside to the reservation may not be at all welcome. In another community far from any metropolitan area and where people are few and far between, challenges may include how to market and distribute products and services.
Although it may not feel like it at the time, the uniqueness of each reservation really does open up opportunities for everyone. For instance, in one community, serving as a fiduciary for Tribal VR funds resulted in tribal officials assuming a managerial role regarding each person served by the program. Officials second guessed rehabilitation expenditures, and began requesting confidential information about persons with disabilities that they thought they needed in order to approve or disapprove businesses. Of course, the Tribal VR program stood by its obligation to assure confidentiality regarding those it assisted. As conversations were held back and forth between the Tribal VR professionals and the Tribal Government staff and council, several areas needing attention emerged. First, everyone realized that the small business owners with disabilities who were being assisted by Tribal VR staff were being subjected to a level of scrutiny and “hoop jumping” that others in the community were spared. This heightened scrutiny was a direct, though unintended result of the tribe administering the VR program’s funds. Another realization that emerged was that the tribe had no overall process for issuing business licenses and examining a potential need for “zoning” in the community. As a result, the tribal government is beginning to engage in a full-blown “futures planning” process that will address some of these issues equitably and efficiently for all members of the community. In the process, the VR staff found a temporary solution by assigning a numerical code to each consumer and submitting paperwork to the tribe identified only by the code numbers.
In a different community, bordering a national highway but several hours from a metropolitan area, the characteristics of the reservation were such that it was economically important to draw in outsiders. The reservation had made an important beginning by building a rest stop for travelers on the sparsely traveled highway. Persons with disabilities, supported by the Tribal VR program, are adding to that by opening a small restaurant to enhance the offerings at the tribal rest stop.
Partnering
A third area to consider as those of us from outside work with Indian communities is how to share our resources in a respectful and non-judgmental fashion. In some measure this topic draws on the first two areas mentioned: “Community as Experts” and “Sovereignty.” However, because of the added value “Partnering” brings to Indian communities, it is worth addressing on its own. Tribal VR programs do not yet enjoy the permanent funding and Social Security reimbursement that state VR programs enjoy. The large number of persons with disabilities in Indian Country means that resources must be stretched farther to cover more people living in situations often very different from what we think of as mainstream in America. The challenge of serving people with limited tribal resources can be better met by seizing the opportunity to partner with others like state VR, the Veterans Administration, Workforce Investment Act partners, the Social Security Administration, and a variety of other grants, projects, and agencies, as well as volunteers.
It is essential though, for all parties in these partnerships to come to the table with equal good will and willingness to communicate. We have found it helpful for people representing the various partners to let the others know what the parameters are for their program and what, if any, rules or policies apply. Knowing the rules can be a great guide for unleashing creative ideas, which lead to achieving positive, desired outcomes without violating policy. And all the partners each get to claim the successful outcome for their own record keeping because each owns some of that success. Further, every time tribal and non-tribal entities work together successfully, relationships are strengthened, trust builds, and people are better served. As the numbers of successes grow, the occasional unsuccessful situation won’t be blown out of proportion, but will be viewed as the typical occasional occurrence we all experience in this work. Along with the many benefits of partnering, there are also challenges to meet. In many areas partners are miles away so getting together can truly challenge schedules and budgets. In other areas, multiple partners means needing to work effectively with multiple agendas and personalities. But even with these and other challenges, partnering presents an additional opportunity to both survive and thrive.
An additional partnership that has been helpful to the Rural Institute’s Adult Community Services and Supports Department in rendering employment assistance to tribal communities has been our collaborative work with the American Indian Technical Assistance Center (AIDTAC). AIDTAC is funded by the Rehabilitation Services Administration and is administered through the Rural Institute. LaDonna Fowler and Robert Shuckahosee at AIDTAC work with tribes to accomplish employment outcomes through assistance around tribal ADA-like inclusion provisions, the need for Independent Living Centers (ILCs) in Indian communities, and supporting tribal VRs in their relationships with tribal governments. AIDTAC and the Adult Community Services and Supports Department often make referrals to one another and partnered successfully to facilitate cooperative agreements between one of Montana’s ILCs and the four reservations in its catchment area. This cooperation and collaboration were beneficial in helping our staff gain trust and credibility in Indian communities, and ultimately helped to achieve more self-employment outcomes in those communities. AIDTAC can be reached at www.aidtac.org.
Conclusion
We are currently living in times (since September 11, 2001) that may see human service budgets cut to help finance defense and disaster efforts. The prospect of fewer dollars, with more people than ever needing our assistance, underscores the importance of partnerships, the blending of resources, and reaching out to serve all person with disabilities respectfully and equitably.
In many states people living on reservations and working in Indian communities may have only sporadic contact with non-Indians, often centered around the buying of goods and services. As more Indian people, with and without disabilities, begin to be self-employed, the prospect of mutually satisfying contacts among Indians and non-Indians increases. To foster these connections and assist growing numbers of Native people with disabilities to be equal partners in their community economies, all of us, both those from within Indian communities and those of us from outside, will need to work together creatively to respectfully meet these and other challenges so everyone can seize the opportunities available to maximize employment in Indian communities.
"When we walk upon
Mother Earth, we always plant our feet carefully
because we know the faces of our future generations
are looking up at us from beneath the ground. We never forget
them."
- Oren Lyons, Onondage Nation
Native American Small Business Resources
Tribal Business Information
Centers (TBICs)
Tribal Business Information Centers, sponsored by the U.S. Small
Business Administration, provide the following kinds of help:
- access to business related computer software,
- one-on-one business counseling,
- business workshops, and
- business reference libraries (including sample business plans, how-to guides for starting many types of business, videos, and business related books).
Currently there are 18 TBICs, located in 7 western states. Web site for more information: www.sba.gov/naa/tribes
Business Administration
Office of Native American Affairs (ONAA)
The SBA’s ONAA is dedicated to ensuring that American Indians,
Native Alaskans, and Native Hawaiians seeking to create, develop,
and expand small businesses have full access to business development
and expansion tools available through the agency’s entrepreneurial
development, lending, and procurement programs. ONAA administers
the Tribal Business Information Centers project. The web site
includes access to a listing of Section 8(a) certified Native
American businesses, and a complete listing of TBIC locations
and the services they typically provide. Web site for more information:
www.sba.gov/naa
Native American Business
Alliance (NABA)
The purpose of the Native American Business Alliance is to facilitate
mutually beneficial relationships between private and public businesses
with Native American owned companies, and to educate communities
on Native American culture. Its focus is on helping Native American
companies become part of the supply base to corporate America.
The Alliance currently includes over 200 Native American companies,
with corporate sponsorships including Toyota, Honda, GM, Ford,
Chrysler, Universal Studios, Walt Disney, and Square D.Web site
for more information: www.native-american-bus.org
The Oklahoma Native American Business Enterprise Center (OKNABEC)
The purpose of OKNABEC is to provide technical assistance to federally
recognized tribes and Native Americans who are interested in starting
a business or enhancing their present business. Services include
assistance in preparing business plans and financial proposals,
procurement information, human resource development training,
resume development, and employment referrals. Web site for more information: www.indiansbusiness.org
National Center for American
Indian Enterprise Development (NCAIED)
The mission of NCAIED is to develop and expand an American Indian
private sector that employs Indian labor, increases the number
of tribal and individual Indian businesses, and positively impacts
and involves reservation communities, by establishing business
relationships between Indian enterprises and private industry.
Its services include:
- feasibility studies,
- business plan development,
- entrepreneurial training,
- financial forecasting and budgeting, and
- web page development.
NCAIED operates Business Development Centers in Arizona, California, and the Northwest, and provides fee-for-services management consulting nationwide. Web site for more information: www.ncaied.org
U.S. Department of Labor
INAP Partnership
INAP (Indian and Native American Programs) maintains
a web site to provide general information about the Workforce
Investment Act Program intended to help Indian and Native Americans
to achieve economic self-sufficiency through employment and job
training. Web site for more information: http://www.doleta.gov/dinap/eta_default.cfm
Native American Marketing
and Development Corporation (NAMCOR)
NAMCOR’s mission is to provide marketing, consulting, and
other business development services to businesses owned by Indian
tribes and Alaska Native Corporations. NAMCOR’s clients
provide a wide array of services to federal agencies and commercial
organizations and are all SBA 8(a) certified with annual revenues
between $6-$40 million per year. The web site includes a listing
of special rights enjoyed by tribes and Alaska Native Corporations
under Section 8(a) of the SBA Business Development Program.
Four Times Foundation
Financial and technical assistance for small business owners on
select reservations.
GAO
Economic Development Federal Assistance Program for American Indians
and Alaska Natives. GAO-02-193 December 2001. Web site for more
information: www.gao.gov
Contact Information
Marsha
Katz, Organizational Consultant
The Rural Institute
52 Corbin Hall
The University of Montana
Missoula, MT 59812
(406) 243-2821